This directory lists every consignment shop in Indiana by city. Save 50-90% on secondhand clothing, furniture, and designer items, or consign your gently-used goods for cash.
Indiana has 154 consignment and thrift stores across 12 cities. Whether you're in Indianapolis, Evansville, Bloomington, or smaller towns, you'll find quality resale shops offering clothing, furniture, home decor, vintage items, and designer goods at deep discounts.
Each store has different policies on what they accept for consignment and how they pay sellers. Browse stores in your city to compare their buying terms, accepted items, and commission rates. Most shops pay 40-50% of the sale price when your items sell.
Pick a city below to see all the local consignment stores with hours, what they buy and sell, and contact info.
Loading map...
Indiana's family-focused communities support consignment shops with kids' clothing, sports equipment, and affordable home furnishings. Local consignment stores check for quality, verify designer brands, and do the selling for you. Whether you're in Madison, Newburgh, or across the Hoosier State, these shops give you personal service that online platforms can't match. No shipping, no marketplace fees, and you're supporting local businesses in the process.