Find 2 consignment shops and 1 thrift store near you in Oyster Bay, NY.
Looking to sell? Consignment shops pay 40-50% of the sale price for designer clothing, handbags, shoes, furniture, and accessories.
Looking to save? Thrift stores offer the deepest discounts in Oyster Bay, starting at a few dollars per item, with every purchase supporting a local cause. Compare hours, donation policies, and accepted items below.
Loading map...
Click markers for store details • 🔍 Zoom to explore
101 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Now you can shop consignment stores all over the country, not just the ones near you. Find a designer bag, vintage furniture, or a standout jacket listed in another city, contact the shop, and get it shipped to your door.
33 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Loading map...
Click markers for store details • 🔍 Zoom to explore
Run by North Shore Community Church
Mission: Ministry of North Shore Community Church serving Long Island; proceeds support church programs.
98A Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, New York 11771
Oyster Bay consignment stores pick what they sell. They only take items in great shape, which means you get better quality than typical thrift stores while still saving money compared to buying new. Here's what you'll see:
Oyster Bay's thrift stores work a little differently. You get a wider selection and lower prices, and every purchase supports a local cause. Here's what stands out:
Consignment shops in Oyster Bay sell items for their owners, who earn 40-50% when a piece sells, so you get curated, often designer resale. Thrift stores like Hope Thrift Shop for Long Island run on donations, usually for charity, with the lowest prices and a wider mix. Shop consignment for quality brands, or thrift for budget finds that support a local cause.
Consignment shops in Oyster Bay work on your behalf. You bring in quality items, the store displays and markets them, and when something sells, you split the money. Most Oyster Bay shops take 40-60% as their commission, so you get 40-50% of what the item sells for. There are no upfront costs. The store only earns when your item sells.
These Oyster Bay thrift stores accept donations: Hope Thrift Shop for Long Island. Bring gently used clothing, furniture, and household goods during store hours. Several provide a tax receipt, and some offer furniture pickup.
You'll typically save 50-90% off retail at Oyster Bay consignment shops, and even more at thrift stores, where prices often run 70-95% below retail. A designer handbag that costs $400-500 new might sell for $120-180 on consignment. At thrift stores, expect jeans for $5-8, kitchen appliances under $15, and furniture for a fraction of retail. Consignment gives you curated, brand-name quality. Thrift gives you the lowest prices.
4 stores
2 stores
24 stores
2 stores
13 stores
2 stores
1 store
2 stores
6 stores
3 stores
2 stores
2 stores
2 stores
2 stores
2 stores
2 stores
2 stores
2 stores
3 stores
2 stores
3 stores
3 stores
2 stores
2 stores
2 stores
2 stores
3 stores
2 stores
2 stores
9 stores
2 stores
2 stores
5 stores
10 stores
2 stores
2 stores